St. Augustine had no doubt that powers are ordained of God and even a wicked and sinful ruler has a right to full obedience. Anyone who resists “duly constituted authority” resists “the ordinance of God.” So long as the rulers do not force their subjects into impetus and a conduct which violates spiritual injunctions and the will of God, they should be obeyed without reservation.
Though on the whole St. Augustine, like all Christian thinkers of his time, believed in the doctrine of the Two Swords and the independence of the church and the state in their respective spheres, he was firmly of the view that heresy was a deadly sin and the state has a right to suppress it.
The position of St. Augustine on religious toleration and freedom of conscience was not without contradiction. The argument offered to him proved a weapon in hands of Inquisitionists later on.
Image Source: wp.patheos.com.s3.amazonaws.com
ADVERTISEMENTS:
Augustine’s view marked a clear departure from Aristotle’s about property and slavery. Both property and slavery, according to the saint, are contrary to original human nature. But they become necessary in the actual condition of the fallen man. In the natural condition property is held in common. After the ‘Fall’, in view of man’s avarice and instinct of self-possession it becomes almost impossible for common ownership to work satisfactorily.
Thus, state control and organisation become necessary. In the words of A.J. Carlyle: “Private property is therefore practically the creation of the state, and is defined, limited and changed by the State.” But while the legal right to private property is recognised by the Fathers, “as a suitable and necessary concession to human infirmity the institution cannot override the natural right of a man to obtain what he needs from the abundance of that which the earth brings forth.”
Augustine’s views on war and slavery are also explicated in the context of the sinful condition of man after Adam’s fall. In the ideal conditions of idyllic innocence and eternal peace, war would be unthinkable, but in the present state of strife and insecurity war becomes a necessity.
ADVERTISEMENTS:
Even from the moral and religious point of view, the state must wage war to protect the Empire and to destroy the heretics. St. Augustine, as against the early Christians, approves of military service for the Christians.
He lays the foundation for the theory of “just war” which was developed by medieval thinkers. Like war, enslavement of man by man is also not strictly in accordance with Eternal law. But it is also justified by what Troeltsch calls the Augustinian doctrine of “relative natural law”.
It is both a punishment and a corrective for the sinful act of men. St. Augustine’s views on slavery are opposed to Aristotle’s; they are more akin to Stoicism modified in the light of Christian theology, that is, the notion of the fall of man.